This weeks
article was able to show how through proper planning, hard work, and a little
bit of luck a large scale Enterprise Recourse Planning (ERP) implementation can
be completed successfully. Such a large scale operation comes with extremely
high risk due to the high costs, resources, and amount of hours that will be
spent on training and learning a new system. To make matters even worse it is
almost impossible predict the exact benefits of the new system. It is important
when implementing such a large system to be able to measure the effects of the process
and to be able to administer ERP best practices.
When
Bombardier implemented their ERP system they used their own best practiced
model which in the end was found to be successful. For other companies looking
to make a large implementation there is a world standard for best
implementation practices that range from executives endorsing the project to
the amount of communication that should be made to ensure success. If I were to
go about implementing an ERP system as Bombardier has, I would use the world
standard for best implementation. Due to the high risk of such a project the
goal should be to minimize your risk as much as possible. By adopting the world
standard your company is taking the knowledge of many executives who have
attempted to implement a large system such as that of Bombardier. They have
been able to tweak these standards based on practices that worked and others
that seemed less successful. Unfortunately every business is different, and
just because something works for one business does not necessarily mean it will
work for another. Even with that fact, I still believe these standards would
give my company the best overall odds of succeeding with this implementation.
If
I were a consultant in this situation and I was presenting the case I would
focus on risk. So many of these projects end up as failures and result in the
loss of millions of dollars that I would try and convince Bombardier to
implement the preexisting standards to reduce risk as much as possible. In the
case of Bombardier they have had success in the past with their own strategy
which is a strong argument but as I mentioned earlier every project is
different. In this situation it would be best to attempt the implementation
through the world standard best practice. A great example for a system that
failed would be Montclair. I am not certain whether or not they used the world
standard for best practice but $20 Million later there is still no system.
Perhaps had they used the standard best practices the result could have been
different. If this example did not sell Bombardier on the idea, I would make it
clear how many hours would be spent on planning hours alone. These are precious
hours that could be put toward the implementation of the project as opposed to
the planning alone.
Bombardier Reflection
I was happy to hear during the Bombardier
presentation that the consultants went with the twelve best practice’s as
opposed to making their own or adjusting the twelve. The consultants did a
strong analysis of Bombardier’s first successful implementation and based on
the notes the consultants gave, I believe that Bombardier will be able to
increase the effectiveness of another implementation to 96% - 97%
effectiveness. It was great to see the consultants truly consult in this
situation. At no point did I feel as if I was being sold a product but instead
truly being consulted toward a final thought.
After sitting though the Bombardier consultation I
would agree with my original thoughts of staying with the twelve best practice
steps. The way the consultants graded the C-level on each aspect of the
practices was an effective way to present this case. The consultants focused on
areas they truly believed would bring Bombardier from 93% productivity to a
96%. Had I been one of the consultants in this situation I would have been
focused a little more on the importance of all twelve standards and how, when
properly used, will produce the most effective implementation.
No comments:
Post a Comment