Problem:
Pandora founder Tim Westergren, had
come face to face with a difficult decision regarding his seven year old
company Pandora. Pandora was running out of cash and on pace to be broke by the
end of the year. Upon much deliberation Westergren narrowed his future decision
down to two possible choices, one being a conservative path in which Pandora
pulls back on it’s growth and raises enough money to continue to stay afloat,
or they could take a more aggressive approach through viral growth and exploiting
the first mover advantage. The latter could result in a significantly larger
amount of capital with the possibility of the company eventually going public.
Assessment/Recommendation:
After beginning as a music
recommendation engine for such companies as AOL and Best Buy, Pandora in 2004,
through additional financing, changed it’s name and strategy. Pandora became
Pandora.com, an internet radio that allowed users to enter their music
preferences and hear similar music based on those preferences. Pandora.com
became very successful and grew to over 5 million users by 2007. Then, in March
of 2007 the Copyright Royalty Board instituted a major increase in royalties which
found Tim Westergren believed would kill all internet radio stations, including
Pandora.
Having examined the music industry
as a whole I believe the best course of action for Pandora.com is to as
Westergren would say, “Put the pedal to the metal.” As CDs continue to become
outdated technology and the music industry as a whole becomes digitalized with
internet and satellite radio, Pandora has positioned itself to grow as one of
the industry leaders. Unlike satellite, Pandora’s service is offered for free
and therefore a strong competitive advantage. If Pandora is able to capitalize
on advertising possibilities without scaring away it’s users there is room for
much growth with sustainable profits.
Presentation:
If I were one of the consultants in
this situation I would emphasize the fact that Pandora is one of the leaders of
the internet radio industry recording roughly 5 million users in 2007. With all
the people that visit the site on a daily bases, companies will be competing
for advertising space on Pandora’s site. The industry is still very young and
Pandora can use their first mover status to their advantage. I would also
emphasize the fact that Pandora offers a free service which many users will
prefer to satellite which is fee based. Pandora users will tolerate an increase
in virtual advertising as long as they continue to be offered a free service.
If users do not wish to have advertisements at least they have the option of
paying for the service at a discount to satellite. This will lead to much
greater revenues and allow for Pandora and other internet radio stations to
cover the increase in royalties as well as compete with satellite radio’s
service.
If all goes well and users are
accepting of the advertising on Pandora, it may be time to beginning considering
selling. Tim would be smart at this point to sell to a larger company such as
Yahoo or Google who would be able to devote more resources toward Pandora and
assure the continued success. Westergren and Pandora investors would then be
able to walk away with a very nice payday while relieving themselves of any
risk of future failure.
Pandora
Reflection
Having sat through the Pandora Consultants
in this case, I must say they were very professional in their presentation of
Pandora. They laid out their presentation cohesively and gave detailed possible
consequence of their future possible actions. I know Westergren and the Pandora
team is not necessarily keen on selling the company but I would have to side
with the consultants in this situation and go with my original thought that selling
the company may be the best exit strategy for the group. The consultants came
up with approximately $35 million net benefit if they were to sell which to me
would be a more conservative number but also one that would interest me enough
to make the sale.
The other recommendation I saw as a
viable option was the tiered pricing structure. In this option users can choose
various pricing options based upon how frequently they use the radio as well as
any additional features. The biggest problem with this suggestion is the fact
that many users are loyal to Pandora due to the fact that it is free. In this
case even users who use Pandora on a minimal basis would be required to pay a
small fee which in the long run I believe would lead to a decrease in customer
retention.
Pandora needs to use its free
service to it’s advantage. If I were Westergren I would include advertising for
free users and when I believed Pandora grew to a level that would interest
possible purchasers, I would begin shopping it around for a price that suited
me. With music becoming more and more electronic based I believe the $35
million estimate is more on the conservative side and Pandora could greatly
exceed that evaluation. Pandora could be the future of radio and Westergren
should not give it up without being properly compensated for what Pandora has
become.