I enjoyed
reading the Accenture case this week and learning about how this company was
able to break off from a very successful accounting firm and form a successful
consulting company. The most important part of Accenture’s success had to do
with the way they implemented their IT strategy. Instead of working with many
companies Accenture was able to consolidate all of their IT needs into one
company (Microsoft) which made it easy to have all their applications talk with
each other. Accenture also made the decision to run its IT department as if it
was its own business, and with good decision making and outsourcing they were
able to cut costs by millions. Having implemented this successful strategy
Accenture now had another difficult decision of whether or not to implement
COBIT 5.
COBIT
5 is a framework created to try and help managers manage the gaps between
control requirements, technical issues, and business risks. The goal is to
create generally accepted information technology control objectives for
day-to-day use by business managers and IT professionals. COBIT 5 has both positives and negatives when
it comes to implementation by Accenture. On the negative side, Accenture has an
extremely successful IT department that is run like a business based on it’s
own set of principles. By adopting COBIT 5 they may need to change some of the
very same principles that made their department as successful as it has been.
On the positive side COBIT 5 is constantly updated with the latest laws and
regulation to ensure that Accenture will not be doing anything illegal that
could lead to litigation of millions.
If
I were the consultants for this case I would recommend Accenture adopt COBIT 5.
With COBIT 5 they will be up to date with the latest rules and regulations
along with being able to operate within any country that has adopted this
standard. With COBIT 5 Accenture’s technology will have an even easier time
communicating with each other due to the fact that they are following a common
set of standards. This would be my argument
for the executive board to take the risk of investing in COBIT 5. If this were
to not completely convince them I would once again focus on the importance of
their IT division being centralized. I would make the point how becoming
centralized worked so well for the company in their first IT decision and how
once again this could improve their IT business structure. Accenture has thousands of employees that need to be able to communicate with each other all over the world and if they are all using the COBIT standard communication will become much smoother.
Reflection
Reflection
The consultants for Accenture really raised the bar
this week when it came to their presentation. Their slides were very well done
and they were able to show a strong understanding of the industry and the
dilemma Accenture is facing. The consultants provided useful insight on both
sides of the argument, to implement or not. I really felt that this group
consulted as opposed to try to sell a product.
Having sat through this consultation I would still go with my original
decision to implement COBIT5. With Accenture being an international company and
communication being such an important part of their success I believe the
investment in COBIT5 will make be worth the $50 million to implement. COBIT5
will allow all employees to work with the same rules and standards allowing
them to communicate much easier than their current situation. All companies
must take risks to operate and COBIT5 is a risk I believe Accenture should
take.
No comments:
Post a Comment