Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Procter & Gamble: Electronic Data Capture and Clinical Trial Management: With Reflection Included


Proctor & Gamble is faced with a situation that many companies are faced with. The problem is the time it takes to get there product, in this case pharmaceuticals, to their consumer. Proctor & Gamble had discovered a lag in the process of getting the product documents locked and ready for final inspection in their documentation process. To help make this decision P&G has contacted a consulting group to assess various alternatives on the future of their database and documentation process.


The speed at which documents are finalized has become an issue at P&G, and they are faced with three alternatives to improve the problem. P&G needs to find a solution to their problem that will be quicker than their current paper process, safe and secure, and user friendly for employees that are currently using a paper based process. If all three objectives can be met P&G will be able to get their product to selves 3 to 4 weeks quicker which is critical due to the fact that every day a product is delayed it costs the sponsor roughly $1 million in lost sales.


The first alternative that P&G must consider is improving the Paper-Based Process. P&G employees are already comfortable with this process and would have little trouble adapting to the changes. Unfortunately there is a limit to how fast a Paper-Based Process can be completed and therefore has little upside. The next option is Digital Imaging. This process is very similar to the Paper-Based Process except for the method of transferring documents. Documents could be faxed and digitally received and stored within the system. Clerks will have split screen computers to enter the data with a document image created on the other side. This process too has limited upside and would require training in database entry as well as general computer knowledge. The final option is to convert to a Web-Enabled EDC. This would be tough to implement due to the fact that it would require much training to ensure that employees have the proper knowledge to access and use this program. Along with that, P&G would need to update it’s facilities to be able to allow internet access to all employees as well as ensuring the connection will be quick enough for use. On the other hand if this process is implemented and successful there is huge potential for improvement and the time it takes to process documents can be more than cut in half.


If I were in the situation of the consultants I would logically have to recommend the Web-Enabled EDC. Though the initial startup costs are steep and it would require much training the Web-Enabled EDC has a much high return in the long run. Employees, once comfortable with the system, will find it much more enjoyable than having to handwrite all of their binders as well as the fact that their work will be  viewed in a much quicker manner. Once the process is instigated P&G will begin to see profits increase over $20 Million per product.
 

If I were to present this case I would sum it up by informing P&G of the safety and ease of use of EDC. Employees will be much happier due to the amount of time that is saved in their preparation as well the amount of time that is saved while waiting for a review. My final sell would be the potential for profits. Everyone is motivated by money and the whole reason P&G is considering this process is to increase company profits per drug by reducing time between trials and shelves. I would also keep in mind the issue of safety and less room for human error. The program is password protected and would be very difficult to infiltrate. As far as human error goes, if P&G can keep the documents in fewer hands there will be less exposure to human error.



Reflection on P&G


            Having sat through the P&G case presentation I was happy to see that the consulting group agreed with my recommendation that P&G should use the Web-Based Data Entry system (EDC). They made some strong arguments toward the adoption of EDC and they made it very clear that they believed P&G should make the move away from their paper-based system and that Web-Based Data Entry was the way of the future. As we spoke about in class, I do think that the consultants should have spent some extra time on the other alternatives. The consultants gave very little time explaining any of the benefits of paper-based and electronic imaging which affected their credibility. It made them seem as if they only researched the one method and didn’t even consider the additional alternatives. It is important to remember as consultants that we are not salesmen. The goal is not to sell a product but instead to help guide a company by providing them with all the facts.


            Overall the consultants did a quality job with the amount of time and resources they had for the presentation. They were all dressed properly and portrayed a good understanding of the topic they discussed. One of my favorite parts of the presentation was the back and forth between the c-level executives and the consultants. I felt as if I was sitting in on a true business meeting based on the questions and answer that were given by both sides. I look forward to my opportunity to be involved on both sides of the executive table.

No comments:

Post a Comment