1-888-Junk-Van
is a growing company in the waste removal industry. The business was started by
Marcus Kingo who started the business with the business model “without
bricks-and mortar”. Without the overhead of rent Kingo was able to compete with
the larger companies and offer competitive prices. He purchased three trucks
and hired drivers to help grow his company. Drivers relied on instructions delivered
through an email system, and when this information was incomplete or incorrect,
customers suffered the consequences. Kingo came across many problems in the
beginning that caused errors in the customer contact information, forgotten
emails, manual calculations and billing mistakes that began to damage the
company’s reputation. Kingo also realized that the most serious of the problems
originated with the data clerk. Kingo did not think it was the employee but the
data entry process was the reason for the errors. Kingo need to make a decision
so he began to research various techniques.
The
first option Kingo had was Microsoft Access. Licenses for Access were a bit
steep at $179 per computer but did provide remote access through a private VPN.
Though this is what he was looking for it did not seem easy to set up the
remote access and would most likely require outside technical support. The next
option was custom application. Kingo could work with developers to build a
program that would fit he needs but the cost would be an upfront price of
$2,000 with maintenance coming at $60 per hour per developer. This option came
with a lot of risk and due to the very high costs and uncertainty of the final
product. A free option that Kingo could go with is Google Docs. The cost is
free up to 10 users with an option of $5 per user per month or $50 per user per
year for small businesses. The program was online based and could be adjusted
by users from various locations. The biggest problem was Google Docs did not
provide the forms that Kingo needed and they provide no formal customer
support, and the thought of cloud computing frightened Kingo as well. Kingo
also had the option of Platform as a Service(PaaS). PaaS allows users to
utilize common applications, as well as build their own unique application,
using a shared computing platform that was provided and hosted by a third
party. The service cost was anywhere from $300 to $600 per month and had a customization
fee of $180 per hour. Another bright side to this decision was the fact that
there were no long-term contracts and the service could be cancelled within one
month’s notice. Finally was the option of Enterprise Resource Planning System
(ERP). ERP’s are built around a central database designed to be accessible remotely,
and allows for business processes from purchasing, sales, customer service, finance,
human resources and e-commerce. This had more processes than Kingo need and
would be about $2,500 per user per year which is more than he would like to
spend.
If
I were the consultants in this case I would recommend option four PaaS. Kingo
would be able to customize the forms as he wishes for a modest fee and the
ability to get out of the contract with only a months’ notice. His employees
would be able to access documents on a safe server provided by a third party.
The investment would easily be made back by the amount of errors that will be
saved with this product. PaaS also offers an onsite trial. Kingo would be able
to get a strong understanding of what he would be getting before he even spent
a penny.
In
presenting this case I would be sure that Kingo knew all the pros and cons of
each alternative.
With
this I would focus on cost and function. Kingo needs a product that will be
simple, meet his requirements, as well as not costing him an arm and a leg.
Slowly we could eliminate different alternatives that did not fit our requirements
until we came to an agreement of a database service.
1-888-Junk-Van Reflection
This was once again a strong consultation as to the future
of 1-888-Junk-Van. I am glad the consultants pushed for PaaS. I believed as
well that this would be the best fit for Kingo and his company. As for
comments, I think the consultants spent too much time on the history of the
company and what they do. The company knows exactly what they do and there is
no need to spend any time going over that. Another criticism I had would be
that they did sound a lot like salesmen as opposed to consultants. Though they
did go over all the options, they really pushed strongly for the PaaS option. Overall
they did a good job with the presentation and handled the Q&A well. Had I
been one of the consultants I would have made the fact that PaaS does not require
a long term contract a big part of my presentation. With the rate that technology
is changing it is important to have the ability to change with it and they fact
that PaaS does not require a long term contract can be a deal maker.
No comments:
Post a Comment